My copy of Gray’s Anatomy lies sprawled out
on the kitchen island, stranded and battered.
It is just one of many medical books scattered across the apartment. Bound in frayed red silk,
spine snapped, it wears the marks of my violence as
one who’s resigned to its fate—from makeup stains
to brown cup rings. Red pen marks run through its
white pages like a network of exposed veins.
I’ve recently become obsessed with what goes
on inside my body. Not the body, but my own body.
I’m trying to figure out the parts of me that are
perpetually in pain, the kinds of pain that no one
can see because there are no bruises or physical
wounds to point to on my black skin. It’s like all
the places that ache inside me are wearing a cloak
When I go see my doctor, he makes jokes about
the “general” in his title. He laughs and laughs and
laughs and then prescribes painkillers that don’t
last. When I become a bit frantic and insist that my
pains are real, he hands me forms filled with boxes
and check marks.
“If something is there, it’ll show up in your blood,”
he tells me. I resist the urge to ask him what if nothing
shows up—again. What then? Can blood not tell lies?
That night, I dream that my body is streaked
through with lightning as sharp as razor blades.
White-hot bolts of pain ignite in my lower back but
shoot up my spine to my head. The migraine is heavy
enough to keep me under, asleep. The pain clogs my
throat and shows me premonitions of terror—eyeless,
mouthless shadows that make the bile in my stomach
rock back and forth.
When I finally break through the surface, I crawl to the bathroom, retching the whole way. The
featureless shadows follow me from sleep and hover
over my sweating, shivering frame in the dark on the
As I wait for the oven in my brain to cool down, I
think about all the things that have ever happened to
me. If I concentrate hard enough, I can remember a
time before pain permeated every part of my life—a
time before my body betrayed my youth.
High school sock hops. First kiss do-overs in dark
stairwells. Scouring the lakeshore for perfect disc-shaped stones.
Now, the world is filling up with things that trigger
all my invisible pains. The bathroom is full of them.
Fluorescent lights. The incessant ticking of the baseboard heater. There’s a cilantro-scented candle my
boyfriend loves to light. I used to be able to tolerate
the scent, but now it reminds me of the way cilantro
tastes of soapy weeds.
I make it back to bed but can’t fall asleep without dissolving a pill under my tongue. By now, the
migraine is a dull pulsing at my temple. My eyes
are clearer, and the shapes in the dark slowly fade; I
almost miss them. If that sounds like madness, then
perhaps it is. Maybe madness is the accumulation of
a life lived in pain, and pain is the only way to be as
alive as possible.
I pay for the blood tests because hospitals are
spilling out onto parking lots, and I can’t afford to wait.
The nurse at the medical lab who tries to draw my
blood does so blindly. She binds my arm, taps the
brown ridge in the crook of my elbow, and sticks the
needle where my veins should be visible, her aim a
The vial stays empty, and my stomach fills up with air.
“Maybe try the other elbow,” I suggest after a few minutes. I’m
barely taking breaths, and the walls around us are slowly closing
in. It’s clear from the way she presses her lips that she does not
want to be told how to do her job. There are special rules that
exist between nurses and patients. Rules that lean heavily on
her side and give her authority over my body and what’s being
done to it.
She shifts the needle around, coaxing my blood to reveal itself.
Her light-pink fingernails dig ridges into my flesh, an extension
of her body sending pain into mine.
A flutter of anxiety grows in my stomach, making me feel sick
and cold. I want to tell her to stop. Beyond the window, the rain
begs me to be quiet.
It feels like the whole world has been saying that to me from
The pains started on a Tuesday morning at the beginning of winter.
It was my first year at Dawson College. I was studying law and
society and sharing a small one-bedroom apartment with my
best friend, Noémie, in one of those red pre-war buildings from
the 1900s. There was one heater controlled by our granite-faced
landlord and an ancient gas stove that hissed loudly if you turned
its dials too high.
I woke up restless after failing to sleep more than three hours.
I could hear Noémie’s snores coming from the living room where
we’d set up a “nest” made of all the soft things we could afford
on a student budget: a bread-thin mattress, a pile of blankets
and pillows, old sweaters for extra padding and warmth. We
took turns every other week on the twin-sized mattress in the
bedroom—our idea of luxury.
Not wanting to disturb my friend, I tiptoed to the front closet
and grabbed my windbreaker and running shoes. Jogging usually
cleared my brain of any foggy debris from a night spent between
sleep and wake.
A steady freezing rain fell, making the air hard as I walked
out the front door. The season was just getting started, and
frost coated everything: the trimmed-back branches of trees,
the cracks in the pavement, even the mud in the construction
sites was firm with it.
Somewhere in between one chemin and another, I started to
run. Below-zero-degree temperatures seep into your pores like
pins, but it was a pain I was familiar with and knew would melt
away as my body warmed up.
I remember how good I felt in that early morning moment.
No cars rushed by, honking hostilities. No one pushed past me
speed-talking into a cell phone. I was alone in the world, and
that aloneness was like a salve for my sleep-deprived mind.
I don’t know how to put into words the violence of the pain
that knocked me to the cold ground. Except to say I felt it too
much and everywhere at once.
Coal fires burned in my head, chest, and rib cage and sent a scorching-hot nausea rolling through my stomach. It was the most physical thing I’ve ever experienced.
The pain took my breath and pressed down on it so hard that
every exhale came out as a wheezing noise. When I tried to stand,
bright flashes made my head spin. There, on the deserted street,
under the indifferent sky, all I could do was fold into myself like
a pocketknife while the pain spread through me. I thought if I
squeezed myself small enough, there would be less of me to hurt.
It didn’t last long; it didn’t need to.
It didn’t last long; it didn’t need to.
Only when I found my breath again did I know I’d survived.
During the next Wednesday, Thursday, and Friday, regular bouts of pain kept me confined to my bed and away from my classes. Each time, I searched the outside of my body for signs of what was going on inside. A bump or bruise. The purplish tint of a rash rising through my flesh. My skin gave nothing away.
By the time Noémie convinced me to go to the hospital, I’d
started thinking of the pain as a growing thing. It swam through
my veins like a swarm of red ants, adding fog to my brain and
cataracts to my eyes.
I’d tried everything to kill it. Drowning it under freezing cold
water in the shower, poisoning it with aspirin and dépanneur
rum. Nothing worked.
At the hospital, the receptionist gave me a sour once-over. “It’s going to be a long wait.” She said it flatly, her grey eyes so hard they gave the impression of stones at the bottom of a frozen pond.
“Can’t say for certain, but you’re looking at ten hours. Minimum.”
“I don’t think I can wait ten hours.”
“You don’t have much of a choice.”
The sound of files being tapped twice against the counter
signaled an end to any attention she was willing to pay me.
I searched for something significant to say to convince this
woman how dire my situation was, but someone cleared their throat behind me. Whatever I was going to say fell away, and I
felt myself dissipating to a black point, an eye floater in the great
white blur around me.
The waiting room was crammed with people struggling
to find comfort on the worn-down plastic chairs or leaning
against the white-grey walls. Most of their ailments were visible. A black eye, a broken arm. An older man wore one pant
leg rolled up, an angry red rash splashed across his pale calf
like spilled jam. He stared at me, and I wondered if he was
looking for proof that I belonged there—physical proof that
my pain was as real as his.
Time moved slowly, oozing along, molasses-like. Everyone
tried for stillness. Whether they meant to or not, they hummed
and moaned in the antiseptic air while, one by one, names were
called—Bennett, Laurent, Martine, Wilson—and bodies changed
chairs with new moans and new wounds and more waiting.
I sat where two walls met—one bright under a stabbing bulb,
the other in shadows—and rested my head in the corner, concentrating on breathing in and out. The pain pushed its way
through my body, warning me to stop moving. Even breathing
It was around 2:15 AM when someone finally called my name.
I heard it in the watery way sleep tries to drown out the world
and make all its trouble weightless. It took me a few seconds to
adjust to the light, a few more to notice the absence of the spiked
thing that had stalked its way through my body for days. In its
place was a nice fuzzy feeling, like being drunk or high or both.
The nurse didn’t wait around to see if anyone followed. She
moved like the wind; keeping up with her was like wading
through warm milk. She was my beacon in bright purple scrubs.
In all this whiteness—white walls, white floor, white doctors in
white lab coats—she shone.
Maybe it was the time of night. Maybe it was my new buzz.
But, everything about her was rapid; the device she aimed at my
forehead, the way she pumped and pumped and pumped my
arm with the blood pressure cuff. She spoke a quick-fire French
that had me grasping at words like I was catching snowflakes
in my sweaty palms.
“So what brings you here?” she wanted to know immediately.
“Um … well, up until a few minutes ago, I was in a lot of pain.”
“Now I feel better than I have in three days.”
“So, you don’t need to see a doctor?”
“No, I’d still like to see one.”
With that, she hmmed to herself and left the examination
room without another word.
Shortly after, the odour of cigarettes, coffee, and cologne
forced their way into the room with the doctor. He was young,
or looked like he was, with slicked-back hair and a Mad Hatter
bow tie. He made me think of those men who never outgrew
their college days and ways—the ones who did surprising things
to be as visible as possible.
“Well, well, well, what do we have here?” he asked in a singsong
voice that matched the tie. He regarded me with something more
than medical curiosity. Something physical, like a hand on my thigh or at the base of my spine.
While I described the last three days of my life, he listened to my chest, back, and lungs. Peered into my eye sockets with a flashlight and a smile.
“And on a scale from one to ten. How bad was the pain?” he wanted to know.
“About a ten,” I replied.
“And now?” he pressed his thumbs into the sides of my throat.
“About a one.”
“So, it looks like I have the healing touch.” He laughed, revealing little black fillings and something green nestled between his molars.
His manner embarrassed me. I was embarrassed that he wasn’t taking me seriously, embarrassed that perhaps I wasn’t explaining myself well enough to be taken seriously. I thought about my mother, about the doctor who had pinched her nipple and winked at her.
“How does that feel?” he’d asked.
I remembered Mom’s outrage and her silence. She had vowed never to return to that hospital but chose never to report the doctor. I vowed to be different, better.
“What do you think caused it?” I asked, keeping my voice level.
“Sounds like you just had a migraine,” he offered.
“So you think I’m fine?”
He reached out and touched my arm. “I’d say you’re more than
fine,” he said. “You’re perfect.”
We are thinking of each other’s blood—the lab nurse and I.
She holds mine in her hands, collecting it in five glass vials with
labels I can’t read. Blood colours her cheeks, ears, and chest—a
crimson shade that belongs to cold weather, passion, and pain.
For a moment, I think I can see everything below her skin.
I try not to look at the place where the needle is siphoning out what’s inside my veins. But it’s hard to look away when blood is the only visible thing that connects me to what goes on inside my body. The slow red drip of it fills my head with hot air and makes me feel so light I float.
“Almost done,” the nurse says.
I feel the pinch of the needle on my arm and think about my
medical books. I think about Gray’s Anatomy with its tattered
cover and gold lettering. About its ripped and wrinkled pages
with Henry Carter’s black-and-white illustrations of arteries,
bones, and organs, and how good it feels to press on its spine
and dig into its pages with my pen. I imagine holding Gray's
pages between my teeth—pages without mention of the word
pain—and thinking of that word, biting down on the textured
paper and tasting its bitterness.
At least you don’t have to worry about bruising,” the nurse says, popping the last vial from the syringe and mopping my arm with a cotton swab.
I want to say something, to tell her that just because my skin hides its bruises doesn’t mean I don’t feel them.
Beyond the window, the rain begs me to be quiet.
Shh, shh, shh.
I listen. ⁂
Chanel M. Sutherland
won the 2021 CBC
Nonfiction and 2022
CBC Short Story prizes.
She was awarded
the 2022 Mairuth
and longlisted for both
Short Story Prize and
the Room Short Fiction
Prize in 2022. She was
also included on the
CBC Books 30 Writers
to Watch list for 2022.